In Darkest London
Ada Elizabeth Chesterton (née Jones, 1869-1962) was a British socialist, journalist, and philanthropist. In 1925, she took up a dare to live in poverty among London's poor. Her experiences, originally published in the Daily Express newspaper, subsequently appeared in 1926 in her book In Darkest London.
Her encounter with the Lambeth workhouse casual ward appears below.
Chapter VIII
THE AWFUL BUSINESS OF THE DOOR-HANDLE
I FIRST went to the casual ward under very melancholy conditions. I was dispirited to find that my entry into commerce had been postponed. I had high hopes as to what I should achieve in the sale of cigarette cases, etc., on commission. But my friend of the plush coat did not turn up. I went to the public-house again that evening, but she was not there. My low spirits were reflected in my trade — I could not get my matches off, and no one would give me more than twopence. I watched the outside of that public house with a sinking heart. I had two coppers on me after a purchase of a cup of tea and a miserable bun, and there was no means by which I could raise any more. My only chance of escaping an unpleasant experience was to go home. But that would have been to confess failure, and when it comes to the fundamentals of life I always develop a certain sticking power. I decided to see this experience through.
The wind had fallen, and a peculiarly unpleasant sleet was coming down, stinging your face and creeping down between the collar of your coat and your neck. I felt as if I had been an outcast for years and I had to take myself in hand pretty thoroughly before I found courage to speak to a policeman.
The outward and visible signs of my destitution were very plain that evening. Unconsciously I had acquired the slinking gait which comes of glancing furtively behind to see if you are being followed by some prosperous citizen with an eye to complaint. It was difficult to hold up my head, my shoulders drooped wearily. I wished very much that I was coward enough to go back to my bed. But I knew that such a course would cut me off from the knowledge I was so desperately eager to gain. To understand how an outcast feels, you yourself must be outcast.
"Where is the nearest casual ward, please?" I asked a young policeman.
"There's only one for women, and that's in Great Guildford Street, Southwark. You'd best go over Westminster Bridge and then enquire your way."
I followed his directions and, much buffetted by cold and rain, found myself in the Kenington Road. I was directed to a workhouse near Lambeth Walk, where I interviewed the porter. He explained that his establishment was for men only, but that he would give me an order which would admit me to Southwark.
Furthermore, he handed me a red counter, marked with the mystic figure ONE.
"If you give this to the tram conductor, he'll give you a ticket," he explained.
"What shall I have to do at the Workhouse?" I asked, rather frightened.
"Oh, nothing very terrible, my dear," was the cheery reply. "They'll take your money away till the morning, that is, if you have any. You can't go in with more than a shilling, you know."
My resources, I explained, were twopence, and I got into the tram, feeling as though the eyes of all the world were on me.
"Fares, please," said the conductor, and then I surprised myself.
Something in me asserted itself, and I leaned forward in my best social manner, in marked contrast to my dilapidated clothes, and handed the conductor the counter.
"Stop outside the casual ward, if you please, I said.
The woman next to me edged farther along the seat, but none of the others took any notice. The conductor beamed at me genially, answered "' Certainly, Miss," and gave me a ticket.
I was awfully glad he called me "Miss,' because it seemed to show that those other outcasts who had handed him their counters had been treated just as nicely.
He stopped at the nearest point to the House and wished me good luck very cheerily. I found the entrance to the casual ward with difficulty — the walls seemed very high and the night was dark. When, at last, I unearthed the bell, the long clanging peal was ominous. Automatically the door opened, and the porter told me to come inside.
He was a nice looking young man with bright eyes and a great sense of humour.
"What's your name?"' he asked.
The inevitable "Annie Turner" duly came forth.
"Where were you born?"
The question seemed to me ridiculous.
"I don't know, I answered.
"Now, that's a pity," said the porter. "Where did you go to school?"
"Manchester," I said, lying boldly.
Age came next, colour of eyes and hair, and then — "What's your height?"
"Now why on earth," said I, "do you want to know that for?"
The porter bent towards me confidentially. "The Minister of Health's very interested in your height," said he. Whereat I determined that the Minister of Health should be fully satisfied.
Now I have always wished to be a tall woman and Fate having brought me the opportunity I gave myself five foot nine inches, which the porter, highly amused, duly entered up.
"Now you go on upstairs," said he, "and the female attendants will look after you."
It has been said that this particular porter is cross-tempered — some of my fellow casuals have whispered it with bated breath. For this reason, I should like to say, he is one of the nicest people I have ever met and I hope in a future life he will be attendant to St. Peter:
I was received by a young woman seated at a table, who put me through the identical catechism framed by the porter. These preliminaries over, she explained, quite nicely, the position of the woman admitted to the casual ward.
"This place," she said, " as you know, is run by rules decided by the authorities. They are not made by us, but we are responsible that they are carried through. I hope you will see your way to conform to them."'
This reception, I admit, was a great surprise. I had thought to find Bumble rampant. I had expected to be treated with ignominy, if not with derision. I found nothing of either. The attitude of all the officials with whom I came in contact was quite human. There was nothing in their manner that could possibly affront that fundamental dignity born in the meanest of mankind. I was destitute, but that did not impair my inalienable right to human treatment. Throughout my stay I was never once made to feel I was a pauper.
"Have you any money?" asked the young woman.
I handed her my twopence and asked if I might keep my nightdress.
"We supply one," she answered. "I am sorry, but you must not take anything with you into the ward."
I solemnly handed over the contents of my packet, together with a dilapidated powder puff, the one thing that had not been taken from me in the doss house.
"If you have any private papers, or letters I will seal them in a packet and keep them for you until the morning. We have no desire to pry into your affairs; you understand that?"
I had not any papers, and I explained that I had spent the previous night in a doss house and should enjoy a hot bath immensely. She led the way into the bath room, and I had a hot tub, with decent soap and a good sized bath towel. The attendant watched me fairly closely.
"Why you're quite clean," she said, and seemed remarkably astonished. 'It's such a relief," she continued, "to find someone who isn't dirty. By-the-bye, is your head all right?"'
I bowed for her inspection, and my hair passed muster.
"You've no idea what some of them are like, you know. We have women in here who are 'fairly alive."
"They can't help it, really, can they?" I said protestingly. "Its difficult to find the money for a wash, let alone a bath."
"But it's unfair to the others, all the same." said the young woman, "and the worst of it is some of them won't let you touch their heads."'
It was not any good to argue the point, and her attitude is quite explicable. It is not a nice job to have to "cleanse" heads riddled with lice. As I have said a number of outcasts decline to let their hair be interfered with. A small percentage, however, yield to necessity and submit to treatment.
The particular official who is on duty has to tackle the proposition with results unpleasing to a sensitive stomach. Generally speaking, when the offending head is shaved, and excavations conducted under the scalp — for lice burrow deep — the patient is exhausted. For it is a strange thing that, deprived of this mass of obscene life, the body seems to grow weak, and frequently a day or two in bed in the infirmary is necessary to restore normal conditions. It may be that the unceasing irritation which would drive most people almost mad, serves as a kind of counterblast to the mental stress of seeking food and lodging. In other words, the ceaseless activity of the lice may prove an anodyne to the pangs of starvation. Remove the artificial stimulus and collapse sets in.
I followed the bright-faced young woman along a bleak corridor, dressed in the workhouse nightgown, a striped garment, fastening at the back, with long enveloping sleeves.
"Leave your clothes on the floor outside the door," she said, "they'll be inspected, and, if necessary — baked."
This was a polite way of telling me that should my garments prove to be verminous they would be dealt with. There is always a hot chamber working in the House. Sometimes the clothes suffer as well as the insects, and the unfortunate casual gets back a singed skirt, or a scorched petticoat. I was put wise as to this by a wonderful woman, by name Kitty Grimshaw, one of the finest characters on the road.
"If they burns your clothes, me dear," she said, "they're bound to make 'em good, the law says so, and I stands by the law."
There is nothing indeed about the law as it applies to the Workhouse that Kitty does not know. She is like one of those old soldiers, who have mastered King's Regulations so completely that they can trip up a superior officer at any minute.
"Law is law," Kitty always says, "and don't you forget to let the Master know you know it."
I was given a mattress, a pillow and a pair of blankets, and told to take them into my "cell" — word of ill omen. It sent a shudder through my body. I do not understand why the word "cell"?" is employed, unless it be that it is so exact a replica of the prison variety that even the official sense of humour would boggle at another name. Still, cubicle might be tried; it would not have so ominous a suggestion.
I was left in the darkness very much alone. I had been oppressed with the sense of sleeping humanity the previous night; I had been surrounded by an atmosphere that would not let me rest; but in the terrible isolation of my cell, my soul ached for the company of the women with their unspeakable bundles, their rabbit skins, their "mog."
High up in the wall was a tiny, round window, like a port-hole, far beyond my power to reach. There was a little observation shutter in the door; now and again it was lifted and the light from the corridor outside peeped in.
The mattress was not too hard, the blankets soft and warm, but the pillow was as stiff as a log of wood. It is as though the Guardians feel the casual must not have comfort everywhere. This policy is part of the determination to prevent a return visit. Thus, you may stretch your limbs, hug your arms under soft fleecy wool, but your head shall find no ease. To and fro — to and fro, you turn on that torturous pillow.
The "cell," slightly funnel-shape, is like a coffin, as it suddenly occurred to me. I felt myself entombed in an instant, cut off for ever from the light of day. 1 wanted to scream — a sob choked my throat — I was getting hysterical — and I knew it. And over and above all this quaking of the flesh, and shrinking of the spirit, was another and more dreadful piece of knowledge. I knew that if I tried the handle of the door it would not open. No handle was there. I could not escape from my funnel-shaped coffin, I might beat my hands upon the wall, but I could not get free.
I felt that if I went to the door and ratified my instinctive suspicion I should be unable to control myself. So I kept quiet and would not go to see what I feared was true. But in the grey dawning when I was quieter — though I had not slept — I crept out and went towards the door. And it was even as I had thought.
Some months ago there was a case in the police court, where it was alleged an inmate of a casual ward was "locked" in her cell. The superintendent stated upon oath that this was not so. "There are," he said, "no keys."
I know of no better example of the letter of the truth — and the violation of the spirit. There are no keys, but, as I have said, when the casual is duly in bed, the handle of the door is withdrawn.
The official explanation of this device would appear quite reasonable. It is said that if people could open their doors and come out of their cells, they would visit each other all night. One or two convivial spirits might, perhaps, drift into the corridor, but for the most part the casual is so dog-tired that any such spirit of enterprise is knocked out. But even were every casual to emerge, an attendant on night duty could shoo them back with the warning that if they came out again they would be shut in. It is as I have said, the Guardians do not desire to extend hospitality too often. Therefore, they inflict slight penalties upon the body and the soul, which, in the aggregate, make up a sum sufficiently imposing to make a night in the ward a thing most strenuously to be avoided.
I had always known that the Guardians deliberately adopt this régime, that their chief intent is to keep casuals "out, not to welcome them in. But to know a thing and to experience it is widely different. I wish some of the guardians could be "destitute" and try their own wards.
We were aroused the next morning about half-past five. The cell door was open. I found my clothes outside the door and put them on in the dim light. I could see other figures also putting on their clothes up and down the corridor. It was a queer experience. Things always seem fore-shortened in the half- light before the night is utterly faded away and the morning come. When we were all dressed we folded up our blankets and carried them with pillow and mattress to the end of the corridor from whence they were despatched to be fumigated. Outside each door the number is painted in bold figures — a discovery which somehow made me feel more than ever like a convict. We were then shepherded into the day room, a mournful place with bare boards, whitewashed walls and a long trestled table. There was no fire in the grate. Large tin mugs full of what was supposed to be tea were placed on the table together with slices of bread spread with a particularly distasteful brand of "marge."
After a bad night every woman aches for a cup of tea, and I do not think I ever felt more disappointed than when I found the liquid in the tin mugs to be loathsomely lukewarm. I could have cried at this uncalled-for rebuff. I was prepared for weak or unsweetened, but not cold tea. This piece of foolish unkindness, as I have said, is now remedied. The tea made for the men is poured off into an urn which sings merrily on a gas ring until required.
I tried to munch a piece of bread, but the marge was more than l could stomach, and feeling rather light in the head and unhappy about the heart, I sat on a form and observed my fellows.
The hour for leaving the House from the casual ward is somewhere about half-past seven. A good few were going out that morning and I listened with interest to their plans. One woman, young and good looking, was anxiously asking how she could get from Southwark to Dulwich, because she had no knowledge of London and possessed but a few pence. She was an ironer by trade and should have had little difficulty in getting work. It was Kitty Grimshaw who told her what to do.
"Get the other side of Westminster Bridge, me girl," said she, "and ask a likely looking chap the nearest way. As like as not he'll give you a copper."
The young woman departed, and her place was taken by a gaunt female who came to the same fountain-head for information.
She wanted to know the best casual wards on the road to Tunbridge Wells, and once more the fine old Irishwoman came to the rescue. Kitty has a strong, handsome face. She is over sixty, but quite upright, with a wealth of greyish hair and quick, humorous eyes. She is a most efficient woman and, as she told me, can plant a field of potatoes with any man, and is first on the list for a number of fruit pickers. She is well-known at Southwark, where she returns every month or six weeks. She has been on the road for some eight years, driven there by that economic pressure which has dehoused so many women.
She lived for some time in a room in Kennington, supporting herself by daily housework, with occasional incursions into a laundry.
"And then, me dear, they wanted me room, so they could get more rent — and somehowes they managed it and I've been on the road ever since. A fine, healthy life it is, and many's the helping hand I get, though — "' she glanced at her feet, "boots is me trouble. You're new to the House, me dear," she added, "but don't you worry, I'll put you right, so that you'll know what to do when you come again."
It was at this moment that a short, stugger little woman with a red face claimed attention. She was very agitated and most aggrieved. It seems that her vest, which had been fumigated with the rest of her clothes, was missing from her bundle, and leave the House without that vest she would not. The attendant on duty, a kindly young woman, of great humanity and understanding, had hunted for it up and down the corridor, but nowhere could it be found. Various women were interrogated but not a shadow of a vest was forthcoming. The red faced lady would not budge; the vest was her's, and somehow or other it must be produced.
"And right you are said Kitty, "and isn't it the law? They take your clothes and if they lose your clothes you've got to have the value, and haven't I had many a fight over the same thing and never have I been beaten."
She tossed her head with its ample thatch, due, she assured me, to the constant use of vaseline — "twopence the box and well worth the price."'
Under Kitty's behest a further, furious search was instigated, and at last the attendant, a little weary, brought back in triumph, the most begrimed thing in vests ever to be seen.
"Here it is, Martha, and of all places in the world I found it in the men's room. She looked at the red-faced woman. "Have you been trying to get off?"' she asked.
The sally was received with shouts of laughter. Such a little thing relieves the monotony in a casual ward! Everyone is so pathetically eager to break through the cold officialdom, which, for all the kindness of the attendants — and I found them very kind — is always present.
Martha, being comforted, went on her way, and I found myself left with Kitty and a big battered woman of about fifty, and two others.
Like Sterne's starling, I was beginning to wish to get out. The walls seemed to be closing in on me. I got a little panic-stricken. Supposing this machine with which I had placed myself in contact should held me against my will? Suppose they said that I must stay. Guardians have such plenary powers to use against the poor. I saw myself sentenced to remain permanently in an institution, I remembered with quick alarm the "tests"? by which they measure your intelligence. They might easily find me mentally deficient !
I went to the attendant and asked if I could go. It was then that the jaws of the trap began to close.
"You can't go until to-morrow morning," she said, "unless the superintendent gives you permission. According to law, you've got to give a day's work for your lodging. You are due to go out on Sunday."'
"But — but I've got a chance of work. I may lose it if I'm kept here." Already I could detect it in my own voice that rising note that speaks a nervous excitation. I realised that if I did not keep cool I must arouse official antagonism. Emotional display is terribly contagious in any form of institutional life, and at the first sign the official mind takes fright and closes down on the unfortunate pleader.
"The superintendent will be up about ten," she said, "meanwhile you get on with some work."
She motioned me towards Kitty, and obediently I went and asked what I was to do. Kitty at that moment was cleaning the grate, heaving up great handfuls of ashes — they are not lavish with implements in the House — to a running commentary on life in general and her own adventures in particular.
"There's nothing particular you can do," she answered, "just you look busy, that's what matters."
I found this to be the case. The tables had already been scrubbed; the corridor washed; there were only the brass knobs on the doors that awaited attention. I polished and re-polished with assiduity, But time hung heavy on my hands. A kindly attendant gave me the tip that the superintendent would not like to find me idle, so I traversed the corridor over and over again, loathing each separate handle, to which I applied Brasso with a new and instinctive dislike.
I think I must have looked not very well, for presently the battered woman — her name was Ellen — beckoned me mysteriously.
"Kitty's got some hot tea made for you, dear. I put it in your cell; drink it up, Ill see that nobody catches you."
To this hour I do not know what special pains and penalties were risked by Kitty and the kindly Ellen in the doing of this act of mercy. But whatever punishment they might have incurred they did not worry, and out of the largeness of their hearts, without a thought of themselves, they got me what I wanted that moment most in all the world.
The tea was hot and sweetened, and as I drank, vitality swept back into my blood. Kitty, it seemed, had a small store of groceries concealed somewhere on her person, or on the premises, from which she drew when occasion required. With the genius of her race she had already enlisted supporters all over the building, and Ellen, transmitting her desire, had induced a man on the next floor to supply hot water — tact did all the rest.
I had a chat with Kitty after this refreshment and she warned me very solemnly to avoid certain casual wards.
"Some are good, some are bad, but I manage to get on with them all, except Tonbridge. I can't never go to Tonbridge — never again."
It sounded strangely ominous. I was intrigued as to the fate that presided at this place of doom.
"What happened, Kitty?" I asked.
"It's the law, me dear," she said, "that the Master mustn't put you to work on an empty belly; neither must you be put out of the House on an empty belly, and who should know this better than meself. There's another law, me dear, the Master shan't put you to do any of his private work, unless he pays for the same. An' there was a certain woman that came in with me, an' she told the master that she was by trade a laundress. 'Then you'll suit me,' he says, ' for I've a sight of washing that wants doing.' 'An' I'm not doing your washing,' says the woman, 'an' me wanting was obstinate, an' I'm not blaming her."
"'An' yell do me washing,' says he, 'or yell go to gaol.' 'An' it's to gaol I'll go," says she, an' for all I told her what to say she sat there an' she wouldn't speak. She was given in charge, brought before the Bench an' as I'm a living sinner they gave her fourteen days. The Master never said a word it was his own washing, an' the poor creature never had the wit to speak up for herself."
"And how did you come into the story, Kitty?"
"You wait an' listen, me dear. When he was through with giving the poor thing to the police, he comes to me an' wants to start me washing the floor. I didn't argue, I just said, quite quiet, ' But, Master, that's not the law, an' none should know it better than you — an' me belly is empty an' on an empty belly the law says you mustn't put me to work. An' I'll be pleased an' proud to tell the Bench the same.'
"He scowled at me, but I had me bit of cheese before I scrubbed. I wasn't bearing him any ill-will, but he got a spite against me, an' when it was time for me to leave I had a cup of cold gruel, though something hot in the way of tea is the right of ev'ryone before they leave the House. He wouldn't give me any, so I took the gruel an' hides it in the garden, an then I walks out an' I asks if there's anyone can send me to a committee lady, an' don't you forget, me dear, that's what you've got to do. Always go to a committee lady. I found one right enough, an' I asked her very civil if she'd be kind enough to step up to the House an' see me breakfast. An' she came, God bless her, an' I showed her me gruel. She put the Master in his place an' stood by while I had me cup of tea, an' she wished me a pleasant good morning an' gave me sixpence. But—" — Kitty spat on her blacklead brush — "I can't never go to Tonbridge again."
But for Kitty's entertainment time would have been a heavy burden. There is nothing so enervating to the spirit as a repetition of totally useless work, and the only alternative to the re-scrubbing of tables already scrubbed, the re-polishing of handles already shining, is to pick oakum. This is of all tasks the most cruel. It tears the finger nails and soils the soul; it has no value, social or economic. Oakum is employed, it is true, as hospital swabs, but, like all mechanical, impersonal labour, it is untouched with any satisfaction. Oakum-picking is part of the system deliberately designed to deter people from claiming a night's lodging to which, as members of a community heavily rated, they are entitled.
The same system compels the compulsory detention of any casual until the morning of the second day. There could be no ethical or material objection to any woman doing two or three hours' useful work. This, however, is not the object, which is to undermine all feelings of self-respect, and implant in the mind the belief that poverty is a crime which must be heavily punished. Not by any active or deliberate cruelty, but by the imposition of futile yet degrading denials. This denial of liberty, this abnegation of freedom, is so insistent that only in the last resource will a London outcast go into the House. The case of women on the road is different and will be subsequently dealt with.
Following on the publication in a Sunday newspaper of my article dealing with the Casual Ward, a revision of the rules has taken place. Oakum picking has been abolished for both male and female casuals, and the latter are now permitted to spend two or three hours daily in washing and mending their clothes and attending to their persons. These alterations, with the provision of hot tea at breakfast, already referred to, stand to the credit of the Metropolitan Asylums Board, and though there is still much which awaits reform, these alterations afford me and my fellow casuals cause for thankfulness.
The arrival of the superintendent, a pretty woman, with bobbed hair, aroused my jaded energies. I seized on a duster and rubbed at a door handle, breathing heavily on the brass. My request was explained to her by an attendant official.
"Have you any hope of work?" she asked.
"At Ealing,' I answered, I am sure of a day's charing." Ealing was the first place I could think of.
"Have you been here before?" she asked.
"It's the first time I have ever slept in a casual ward."
"In that case I'll let you go. But you must understand if you come back here within a month you will have to stay for three days; if you return next month, you will have to stay the usual time — a day and a night. On no account will you be let off again."
I wanted to blaze out my sense of the injustice of this rule, but I remembered in time that she was but the instrument and not the law, and I realised that the Superintendent, like the other officials, was far more humane than the institution which they served. Besides, I was beginning to have a wholesome fear of the State; I did not want to be thrust back into that awful cell. The thought of a second night in that funnel-shaped coffin appalled me. I hurriedly thanked her, and turned towards the office to get my hat and coat, powder puff and pence.
But I was not to leave the house without further proof of loving kindness. The battered Ellen came after me and slipped into my hand a thing most valued in the outcast life — a piece of soap.
I followed the attendant down the stone stairs, a very nice young woman, whom I shall always remember with gratitude. She advised me to go to the Labour Exchange and said that daily chars were in demand and she wished me good luck with a bright smile.
The door clanged behind me and I went out into the bleak, raw day, feeling as if I had escaped from the grave. I reeled almost with the sense of liberty, a liberty that my hunger, weariness and great distress could not embitter. I understood then why it is that humanity dreads what is known as organised relief. I contrasted the ghastly regulations of the Workhouse with the warm, unfettered welcome of the Salvation Army, and I knew that if I found myself again in such a plight rather than go to the casual ward I would spend the whole night walking the streets.
And if I felt this in an institution characterised by the humanity of the officials, how intolerable must be the bitterness of a House ruled by insentient force? I thought of Kitty standing up before the master at Tonbridge and fighting the Law, and in my first flush of recovered independence I saluted that fine old warrior battling, not for her belly alone, but for the bellies of others.
There is, I understand, a Union of Poor Law Officials, who, apart from their work of obtaining decent wages and conditions for the members, are steadily striving to alter the regulations governing casuals. In this they are helped by individual guardians. But on the whole Boards have developed little consciousness since the days of Bumble. They have no souls to save nor bodies to be kicked and, while in London, at any rate, superintendents, male and female, have lost that sense of brutal superiority condemned by Dickens, their superiors have remained untouched. In the process of economic evolution, the soul of Bumble has ascended to a higher social plane.
I left before the midday meal, which consists of potatoes, bread, and a little cheese. The evening meal is skilly. The casuals have no tea, except in the morning. I rejoice to think that on this morning on which I write the women at Great Guildford Street have their tea hot; a small thing — but to them a great feat to have accomplished.
Unless otherwise indicated, this page () is copyright Peter Higginbotham. Contents may not be reproduced without permission.